Home Up Comm061899
Co-brand
Partnerships
| |
MORNING
COMMENTS WEEK OF 6/4/99-6/11/99 |
|
6/11/99 |
Silence is golden, but on
a day before two major economic reports it is merely a dingy shade of uncertain yellow.
The Top Fed's silence on the economy during his address to Harvard's Class of 1999 helped
the Dow regain a bit of its composure in the last half hour of trading yesterday, trimming
a 160 point drubbing to a more palatable 69 point loss. Overshadowed by Greenspan's speech yesterday was a 0.7% jump in
import prices, the third consecutive monthly rise. The forces of inflation have been
held at bay, in part, over the past 1 1/2 years by a global economy in turmoil and its
byproduct: falling import prices which took away the ability of American manufacturers to
raise prices. With the world on the mend and import prices once again creeping up,
pricing power is returning to American manufacturers, and with the ability to raise prices
comes the potential for inflation. In short, yesterday's import price data added
another entry to the FOMC's "Reasons to Raise Rates Soon" notebook.
Today's PPI and Retail Sales reports will determine the
fate of the market over the next few days, but the figures will have to come in
significantly below expectations to stave off a Fed rate hike. A flat core PPI
reading (estimates are for a rise of 0.1%) will not be enough to prevent rates from
rising. Stocks will likely rally strongly on weak numbers, but this week's strong economic
figures from Germany and Japan will likely force the Fed to take preemptive action.
With a rate hike seemingly a done deal at this point, the
key question becomes whether the market has already factored in a rise in interest rates.
July Fed Funds Futures are already pricing in a move by the FOMC, and the jump in
30 year Treasury rates above 6% is signifying that the bond market has also factored in a
move. The stock market, however, remains significantly above the top end of its
historical valuation range and has yet to adjust to the rise in rates. While the
major averages have corrected 5-7% from their highs,they remain significantly above their
January 4th levels when rates hit an intraday high of 5.177%.
If the FOMC does raise rates, a scenario in which the long
bond rallies and the stock market declines after an initial relief rally is entirely
possible.
With interest rates above 6%, the question you should be
asking yourself is not "how much has the stock or market fallen from its highs",
but rather the question to ask now is "where is the stock or market trading in
relation to its historical valuation range". |
6/10/99 |
On our morning stroll
yesterday we heard a few scattered cries of , "Mommy, why do they keep talking
about interest rates!?, It's giving me a headache, make them STOP." (We also saw a
few bridges being built on the horizon, but we'll get to that later in the story).
By the end of our walk we noticed that Doctor Chipmaker had arrived and was doling out
aspirin to his long suffering patients. The
medicine seemed to work wonders, as the patients quickly forgot the deafening din of
"6%, the sky is falling, 6% where next", and turned their attention to the
glistening report that Doctor chipmaker was holding in his outstretched hand. The
words in the report brought smiles to the assembled mass, "12.1% growth in the
worldwide semiconductor industry, the first double digit growth since the bottom fell out
in 1995, 19% growth in memory chips, 16% growth in microprocessors, and on , and on".
After taking a moment to ponder the news, the CROWD
quickly rushed with outstretched arms to greet their old flames, the tech stocks.
Now we like a happy ending as much as the next person, but we thought yesterday's
wholesale plunge into tech stocks was a mite overdone. The projections of future
growth are better than expected, but not all semiconductor makers will benefit
equally.
To be specific, we're talking about the microprocessor
market and Intel. Yesterday's report did not answer the key question of: which
microprocessors will experience the growth. We have a sneaking suspicion that it will be
the Intel Celerons and AMD K6's which receive the bulk of the growth, with the higher end
Pentium lll Xeon's lagging behind--a scenario which is not bullish for Intel's profits or
margins.
We also question the sustainability of yesterday's rise in
the shares of the PC box makers. A growing semiconductor industry does little to
change the fact that, despite their recent drop, the stocks still sport high valuations
and are essentially commodity producers operating in a business with falling product
prices. Current forecasts call for the price of home PC's to slip below $500 by year's
end, signaling more margin erosion for the PC makers.
And then there's yesterday's 5% rise in AMAT...Shares of
Applied Materials, which stands to benefit the most from a chip rebound, are now valued at
peak cycle valuation levels, leaving little room for further appreciation. The
large cap NASDAQ stocks in general, despite their correction, remain at valuation levels
which are unsustainable in a rising interest rate environment....Which brings us to those
bridges we mentioned earlier...
The odds of a Fed rate hike increased overnight after
Japan reported that its economy grew a much stronger than expected 1.9% during the first 3
months of the year. The rise in GDP was led by domestic components, capital spending
and consumer spending, which increases the likelihood that the growth was not just a one
quarter affair. The sharp GDP rise also raises the risks of a global reflation occurring
and increases the chances of a Fed rate hike by removing the words "still fragile
global economy" from the Fed's copy of "Reasons to Remain A Dove".
While we continue to believe that the Japanese government's bridge building program (in
official-speak it is referred to as 'public works spending') is similar to a band-aid
being given to a patient who really requires surgery (or in Japan's case structural
change), the fact remains that in the short term the band-aid is helping to ease the pain.
With the easing of the pain the deflationary forces that have kept inflation at bay are
disappearing, raising the risks of inflation.
The market must still digest the Retail Sales and PPI data
tomorrow, and CPI next week, but today's news out of Japan has magnified the risk of a Fed
move, even if the 3 reports come in weaker than expected. |
6/9/99 |
The market's daily game of
uncertainty resolved itself to the downside yesterday. A second warning from the
airline industry, this time from US Airways, and an analyst downgrade of the PC box makers
set the tone for a negative open. Hawkish
comments from non voting FOMC members Broaddus and Poole sent the bond and stock
markets reeling. The yield on the long bond broke through resistance at 5.97% and finished
at 5.99%, the highest in a year. The Dow Industrials lost 143.74 on the day and NASDAQ
shed 49.70, but volume remained anemic on the NYSE, with only 685 million shares changing
hands as trader's remain on the sidelines awaiting Friday's economic reports.
The day's losses were enough to change the intermediate
term trends for the S&P 500 and NASDAQ to the downside once again, but the change in
trend is not a signal for a wholesale shorting of the market. While short term
sentiment remains negative, longer term sentiment remains decidedly bullish and will act
as a temporary cushion to any drop. [NOTE: For a quick and simplified way to measure
underlying market sentiment you can look at the long term trend of the individual Dow
stocks, where 26 of the 30 stocks are still in long term uptrends. Think of the long
term trend as a gauge of investors' belief that the market's long term outlook will be
positive].
While sentiment remains overwhelmingly bullish long term,
the chances of an external shock dealing a mortal blow to the belief that prices only go
one way (up) were increased by 3 events yesterday which increased the chances of a Fed
tightening. The first event was of course the headline grabbing rise in long term
rates to a one year high. Rates are now at a level where stocks with excessive
valuation levels will increasingly see selling pressure. The second event that
increased the odds of a rate hike at some point this year was the downward revision in
first quarter productivity to 3.5%. The economy's primary weapon against the onset
of inflation is now showing cracks, with productivity showing a large decline from the
fourth quarter's 4.3% gain.
The third event yesterday, and perhaps the most serious,
was the announcement by a Japanese official that tomorrow's Japanese GDP numbers are
expected to show positive first quarter growth, breaking a string of 6 down quarters.
The upside surprise will temporarily remove one of the primary defenses against a
Fed tightening at its June meeting: fears of the repercussions a move would have on a
still reeling global economy.
While the chances of a Fed rate hike have increased,
Friday's PPI and Retail Sales numbers, and next week's CPI could quickly negate
yesterday's damage. Caution remains the key ahead of the upcoming economic data. |
6/8/99 |
The Bull Wrecking Crew at
the Fed has been temporarily forced to cede their spot in the limelight as the rate hike
wait marathon takes a back seat to a question that is dancing on the tips of many a
trader's tongue, "Is this rally the start of a new leg up, or is it just a sucker's
rally?". A case could be made that the
past few weeks were merely a bad case of Fed induced indigestion and that the patient has
now fully recovered, ready to participate in the next chapter of the Goldilocks saga.
The 3 day rally has resulted in the market doing an about face, with the short and
intermediate term trends for the Dow, NASDAQ, and S&P 500 once again pointing skyward.
On a purely technical basis, the Dow's short term chart
supports the case for higher prices, with the index successfully holding support and
bouncing off of its 55 day moving average which has acted as a support trampoline over the
past 5 months (see today's Market Chart section for further analysis).
There is another explanation for the market's bounce
however, one that is not conducive to the start of a sustainable rally, namely, the
market's rally has been primarily due to A Paucity Of Sellers. Around here, we're
not about to place long term bets against the gathering storm of an unfavorable interest
rate environment until a ray of sunlight appears between the storm clouds, and we have a
sneaking suspicion many market players are also taking this course of action, as evidenced
by yesterday's scant 654 million shares traded on the NYSE.
The nature of the recent rally, with volume doing a swift
disappearing act as the sellers await further economic data, points to a short lived rally
with heartbreak the end result for those who have eagerly returned to pick up perceived
bargains in their favorite speculative hunting grounds. The reemergence of the large
cap techs and Internet stocks as market leaders points to market weakness rather than
strength. A market that is led by those who have yet to learn that there is a strong
inverse relationship between valuation levels and interest rates is a market that is
swiftly marching to the edge of a cliff without a parachute.
Finally, in an unrelated note, many of you will remember
the belief trumpeted around these parts throughout last Summer and last Fall, at the
depths of the emerging markets exodus, that a buying opportunity was at hand and the Asian
markets would recover from their near death experience. Since that time we have seen South
Korea and the Philippines turn in impressive economic turnarounds, with other Asian
markets showing signs of emerging from last year's depression. Today the Indonesian stock
market joined the recovery parade following yesterday's Indonesian parliamentary
elections, with the market gaining 12.1% to finish at its highest level since before last
year's rupiah devaluation.
Our point in mentioning Indonesia this morning: when
sentiment reaches an extreme, whether it is the extreme despair seen in Asian markets last
year or the extreme complacent bullishness seen in the U.S. market this year, you should
take it as a warning sign of a coming sharp change in the trend and sentiment. |
6/7/99 |
The week begins much as
last week ended, with the debilitating winds of Confusion still firmly in control.
The tale of two divergent cities, Jitterybonds Junction and Frothystock Gulch, will
continue this week as traders bide time awaiting the release of the next magical answers
to the all consuming question, "Will they, or Won't they?". The question that was to be answered last Friday, alas, was not.
Friday's mixed employment numbers were released in two versions: a relief inducing
copy for the stock market, and a fear expanding copy for bond traders. Neither camp
fully understood what they were given to read.
The bond market had a clearer understanding of Friday's
piece of the puzzle, but its sense of timing remains off. The larger than expected
jump in average hourly earnings and dip in the unemployment rate to a 29 year low added to
the already visible signs that the consumer debt financed wealth effect is finally causing
the inflationary beast to stir. The inflationary menace remains contained at this
stage of its reawakening, however, and the Fed will not act without further proof that the
doors of its decade old cage are about to spring open. The bond market was correct
in sensing the danger lurking over the horizon, but it was wrong in believing that
Friday's data was the final piece needed to ensure a rate hike at the next FOMC.
The bond market's premature assessment of the damage done
led to a decline of 11 ticks on the long bond, with yields rising within a hair of
resistance at 5.97%. Watch this level closely this week, a failure to hold below
5.97% will likely lead to a rise in rates to the next resistance level at 6.11%, a level
at which the stock market will be forced to dust off the V(aluations) word.
While the bond market partially understood Friday's mixed
numbers, the stock market rallied without a clue. The number upon which the stock market
fixed its eyes, 11,000, is likely to prove to be merely a transient blip. We expect
the non farm payrolls number to be revised higher next month.
Friday's stock market rally is unlikely to be sustained
for the duration of this week. The rally once again occurred on thin volume (692
million), and the last in to the bull market were once again the first stepping forward to
pick up stocks perceived as bargains, with the crowd pleasing favorites: the large cap
techs and Internet stocks at the top of many a New Era bargain shopper's list.
Classic topping signs continue to unfold, and the ability of money new to the market to
sustain the rally continues to weaken with each successive basis point rise in bond
yields.
After an early week continuation of Friday's
"value" buying, we expect fear to once again dominate stock market sentiment as
the release of this Friday's Retail Sales and PPI numbers draws near.
Caution remains the key to survival until the release of
next week's CPI data. |
|
DISCLAIMER |
|