Home Up Comm062599
Co-brand
Partnerships
| |
MORNING
COMMENTS WEEK OF 6/14/99-6/18/99 |
|
6/18/99 |
A noticeable calm
descended on the assembled onlookers as the Pre-emptive Crusader's oration echoed
forth. He spoke of potential future bumps in the road, of the need to remain
vigilant, but above all it was talk of the future not the present, and the message was
clear to the gathered masses, "a small relatively painless action now will prevent
the need for infliction of far greater future pain". A tide of relief swept throughout the bond pits as uncertainty gave
way to clarity. Yields sliced like a knife beneath the 6% level, settling at 5.95%,
the 50% retracement level of their April 1997-October 1998 decline, with the next downside
yield targets at 5.86% and 5.81% if the rebound were to gather steam, an event which is
unlikely until after the FOMC meets.
The fall in yields below the valuation consciousness
inducing level of 6% stirred a ray of hope for a return to the glory days amongst traders
of the market's fallen heroes: the Internet stocks. While many analysts and fund managers
have proclaimed a bottom in the Internet stocks, we haven't. The Internet stocks
current rally is merely the expected, and normal, dead cat bounce that occurs after an
industry group has suffered a swift 50% decline. We expect the current .com bounce
to retrace 38% of its recent decline before sputtering out. If you're holding the 2
biggies of the .com world: AOL and Yahoo, this means look for the rally in the two stocks
to run out of gas around 125 and 170 respectively.
While bond traders, Internet devotees, and the Market Guru
Supreme of Goldman Sachs are now confident the worst is over and one rate hike will be the
extent of the damage, we're not so sure. The one rate hike take on yesterday's
testimony is nice in theory, but not likely in practice. Greenspan left the door
open for further rate hikes, and the odds favor the door being pushed further ajar in the
coming months. A 1/4 point cut is more flash than substance, it produces an
acknowledgement of action from the crowd, but its ability to pre-empt lurking evils is
severely lacking. The Fed will likely have to take back all 3 of last year's rate
cuts in the coming months if it hopes to "pre-empt forces of imbalance".
Of course, the Fed's hand could be forced to act sooner
than later if the stock market takes off where it left off before the recent ripple of
rate hike jitters began. The level of complacency and extreme levels of bullish
sentiment in the market remained high throughout the recent turmoil, with bullish
sentiment never dipping below 55.9% in the Investors Intelligence Survey. Greenspan
& Co very well might feel the need to rein in this bubble of sentiment in the coming
months if they hope to avert larger problems down the road. The faster and higher
the market rises, the more likely that the hoped for one off rate hike quickly becomes a
series of Fed moves. As the saying goes, "Buyer Beware." |
6/17/99 |
"No chance of a rate
hike now, let's do some bargain hunting!", roared the crowd at the opening bell as
traders everywhere breathed in the smells of a seemingly benign interest rate outlook and
went on a day long buying spree, snapping up shares of companies from Apple to Zoran. Nowhere was the buying frenzy more intense than in the Internet
stocks, where the Goldman Sachs Internet Index soared 14% as investors with a nose for a
bargain snapped up shares after the sector's recent 50% plunge. Forgotten in the
day's buying spree were words only recently learned such as valuation levels, P/E ratios,
and 6% interest rates.
We mention 6% because even with yesterday morning's bond
market rally, interest rates remain above 6%, a level which only last week triggered an
awakening of the concept that bond yields and P/E ratios tend to move in opposite
directions. Even if the members of the FOMC had been magically transformed into
gentle doves upon seeing the CPI data, as many believed yesterday,the fact remains that
stock market valuations have yet to adjust to the rise in interest rates since January.
Since we do not see bond yields dropping back to their January levels of 5.17% even if the
Fed were to leave rates unchanged, and the relationship between P/E ratios and bond yields
has yet to be rescinded, the likely result will be a contraction in the market's P/E ratio
which now stands at 34.5 for the S&P 500.
As we said yesterday morning following the release of the
CPI numbers, yesterday's numbers were not enough to prevent a move at the next FOMC.
The case for a preemptive rate hike actually grew yesterday after the Fed's Beige
Book showed very tight labor markets in all regions and upward pressure on wages.
The Beige Book's warning of inflationary pressures on the horizon wins out over the CPI's
report on last month's inflation data. Preemptive remains the key word. |
6/16/99 |
The financial markets
waited with baited breath for the NUMBER that many felt could spell the end of the
world. Jitters abounded, hands trembled, volume dwindled to a mere speck as the
countdown to the NUMBER consumed all thought. 8:30
dawned, a pair of figures flashed by, CPI unchanged, core up 0.1%, smiles grew wider,
traders rushed to place buy orders: the NUMBER was below expectations. The world was
safe from the Fed Bull Wrecking Crew. The long bond's yield sank to 6.04%, S&P
Futures rallied 14 points.
A trading rally had begun...
...And only a trading rally.
Today's lower than expected core CPI provides the market
with the ammunition for a short term rally, but not with the fuel for a sustainable long
term advance to new highs. The numbers provided relief to many traders, they'll
provide the major averages with a pop to the upside, but they will do little to avert a
rate hike.
We've said it before, but we'll repeat it again: The
Fed's job is to be preemptive in the war on inflation. The
door to the reemergence of inflation remains wide open. The strong rebound in Asian
economies and the surprising growth figures out of Germany and Japan have removed the lid
from the inflationary pot. The global economic turmoil which was the primary weapon
against inflationary bottlenecks developing is now on the mend, and with the healing
process will come an increase in demand and more importantly, an increase in pricing
power.
The Fed is well aware that the Goldilocks economy's secret
defense, the global inflation damper, has been removed and that the pieces are now in
place for inflation to develop. The Fed's recent slew of warnings points to a Fed
that is ready to be preemptive, which means acting before inflation has a chance to work
all the way through the system and show up as a string of worse than expected CPI numbers.
We would pay close attention to Greenspan's speech
tomorrow, and remain prepared for a rate hike at the next FOMC regardless of the speech.
We would also remain prepared in the coming months for the Fed to take back last
Fall's 3 rate cuts. In order to slow the economy sufficiently to keep inflation at
bay, the Fed will have to slow the prime component of recent economic growth: the
consumer, and to slow the consumer's desire to spend the Fed is going to have to slow the
stock market which will take more than one rate cut.
A trading rally, but not a buying opportunity for bottom
fishing long term investors. |
6/15/99 |
Rising cyclicals and
plummeting .coms, premature hopes and unwanted phone calls, told the story of the tape
yesterday. In an age when keeping up with
the Joneses means staying fully invested in the only sure hit money maker in town, money
has to go somewhere and yesterday it went into the perennial laggards turned leaders:
aluminum, oil, paper, and steel. Yesterday's money spent may well turn out to be a
case of fund managers counting their chickens before they're hatched, of premature hopes
based on a story that never unfolds.
Resigned to the inevitability of a Fed move, investors
have begun to focus on the future, and what they see is more of the same, but with a
global kicker thrown in for good measure. The prevailing wisdom is that the unstoppable
U.S. economic expansion will keep chugging along after the Fed moves, and the global
economy will join in the party, with the end result being a United Nations of Goldilocks.
We, of course, beg to differ with this scenario.
The Goldilocks economy in all likelihood is nearing its
end. The much lauded New Paradigm continues to be an economic expansion built on a house
of cards, in this case the self feeding virtual merry-go-round of an indebted
consumer feeding the economy through a belief in a unidirectional stock market. With
the interest rate environment now acting as a damper to "irrational exuberance",
the stock market has likely seen its better days. Without a continued surge in
market valuations, the ability of the New Era to continue as an ongoing entity is called
into question. A consumer spending beyond his means whose financial health is
possible only with a continued rise in share valuations will swiftly be forced to apply
the breaks to spending if the market heads south, and with the demise of the free spending
consumer will come an end to the wealth effect which is now helping to feed economic
recoveries from Kuala Lumpur to Frankfurt .
The use of leverage to achieve the bull market dream only
adds to the dangers, as we saw yesterday when many a gunslinging Internet stock trader
heard the ring of that most dreaded of unwanted calls: the margin call. As the
market continues to work off the excesses which have been allowed to build, we are likely
to see a pick up in the pace of the market's reversion to historical norms of valuation as
the margin squeeze induced rout becomes only too common place.
In January we said there was a need for action to be taken
to take some of the froth out of the market. We called for the Fed to raise rates,
and for brokerage firms to advise their clients of the potential risks building in
speculative areas of the market. Instead of action we saw inaction by the Fed, and
we saw many brokerage firm analysts "touting" the stocks of their
underwriting clients. Unfortunately now the damage has likely been done and the
impending Fed rate hike will be too little much too late, with the American consumer being
the victim of inaction by those who should have known better. |
6/14/99 |
Last Friday's eagerly
anticipated economic data revealed two things: #1. the American consumer remains one happy
camper, and #2. retailers are laughing all the way to the bank as the soothing ka-ching
ka-ching sound of cash registers continues to ring throughout the land. In short,
the New Era of boundless prosperity, of life in a land where recessions have been
banished, continues to rage on unabated. In
a parallel universe, in a place where the land of good and plenty is seen as the precursor
of impending gloom, spirits are not so bright and fear permeates the air. This
forsaken place, the land where good is bad, where each sunrise brings a chill and jitters
have replaced smiles, is the U.S. bond market.
The bond market greeted the release of Friday's as
expected PPI and stronger than expected retail sales numbers with an initial sigh of
relief which was swiftly replaced by a sigh of resignation to the inevitable. The
resulting selloff was not born of fear, but rather of capitulation. Inflation doves,
with their backs against the wall, surrendered to the prevailing winds of change and
headed for the exits, sending the yield on the long bond to 6.15%. Where there is
capitulation, there is usually a short term rebound. We look for yields to retrace
their steps to support at 6.11%, and on a break of support 5.97%, as trader's await the
Big Events: CPI and Greenspan on the Hill.
While awaiting the release of CPI, we would spend some
time contemplating the Fed's role in fighting inflation, for it is in the Fed's methods
that you will receive your answers to the all consuming question, "Will They, or
Won't They". To refresh the memory, the Fed's desire is to act before the
onslaught, to be preemptive. The Fed as a matter of policy does not seek to act
after the fact. The Fed attempts to act before the arrival of the Ghost of Inflation
Present (the CPI), preferring to throw its preventative darts at the Ghost of Inflation
Yet to Come ( the future effects of a pickup in the global economy).
While this week's two Big Events will produce short term
bond and stock market gyrations, in the end they will likely prove to be meaningless
because the decision to act at the end of the month was made before their arrival. |
|
DISCLAIMER |
|