MASTERING
THE TRADE
ORIGINAL, INTERACTIVE
SEMINAR ON TRADING USING
TECHNICAL ANALYSIS
EARNINGS
ESTIMATES
U.S.
QUOTES
U.S.
CHARTS
TECHNICAL
OPINION
CANADIAN
CHARTS
SEC FILINGS
BROKER
RESEARCH
MORNING
COMMENTS WEEK OF 10/04/99-10/08/99
10/08/99
If you look in all the right places, its
turning out to be a beautiful day: inflows into equity funds are strong,
the Dow, NASDAQ, and S&P 500 enjoyed solid rallies, an apparent break in
OPEC's resolve has sent oil prices plummeting, and this morning's non farm
payroll numbers showed surprising weakness. All in all, it would seem, a
good day, and one that speaks of better days to come.
A glance at the broader landscape,
however, shows that things are a little less serene than they seemed at
first glance, and behind each of the bright spots there is a darker story
waiting to be told, a story that could make the outlook for the coming
days and weeks a little less sanguine.
In this
morning's early commentary, we said "We are looking for non-farm payrolls to come in below consensus due to the impact of Hurricane Floyd. While a much lower than expected non farm payroll figure would likely provide the necessary fuel for a market rally....
we would be inclined to regard any such reading as a storm skewed aberration that is unlikely to decrease the odds of further Fed tightening."
Our expectations for a weak number were met, with non farm payrolls
showing a surprising drop of 8,000 during September, much weaker than the
consensus expectation of a gain of 220,000.
While
Hurricane Floyd's impact played a large part in the weaker than expected
payrolls numbers, we would not be so quick to regard the remainder of the
drop, or the downward revision in August numbers, as a sign that the
economy is slowing.
Rather
than a sign of slowing economic activity, the deceleration in non farm
payroll gains over the past 2 months, when combined with September's
stronger than expected 0.5% surge in average hourly earnings, is more likely a
sign that employers are having a hard time finding qualified workers in
the shrinking pool of available applicants and are being forced to raise
wages to fill positions.
On
Tuesday the Fed said, "...the growth of demand has continued to outpace that of supply, as evidenced by a
decreasing pool of available workers willing to take jobs. In these
circumstances, the Federal Open Market Committee will need to be especially
alert in the months ahead to the potential for costs to increase significantly
in excess of productivity in a manner that could contribute to inflation
pressures and undermine the impressive performance of the economy."
Today's non farm payroll
numbers, rather than being a positive that will decrease the threat of a
move by the Fed, are instead the exact type of numbers that the Fed warned
could trigger inflation and force it to hike rates at a future meeting.
While
today's employment data increases the odds that the Fed will be forced to
act before year's end to quell developing inflationary pressures, today's
numbers should not be regarded as the definitive answer to the question
"will they raise rates before year end". The Fed will need
to see further evidence of inflationary pressures in upcoming data
before making a final decision. The October employment report now
takes on added importance. If the wage pressures shown by the
September numbers make a repeat appearance next month, look for a November
rate hike to be a done deal.
Aside
from the employment report, today's other bright spots also appear a bit
dimmer, and grayer, on second glance.
The
strong inflows into equity mutual funds during the past week were largely channeled
into large cap equity funds, which enjoyed their strongest inflows in 5
months, according to the latest figures from AMG Data.
The
public's preference for the largest of large caps is evident in today's
market, as the large cap averages (along with the oil sensitive
transports) surge, while the midcap and smallcap averages are left
behind. While the S&P 500 and Dow finished the day with better
than 1% gains, the S&P midcap 400 lost nearly 1%, and the Russell 2000
ended the day with a marginal loss.
The
narrowness of today's rally is also apparent in today's advance/decline
numbers, with decliners leading advancers by 70 issues on the NYSE, and
up/down volume in a dead heat. In short, the divergence between the
haves (narrow basket of large cap crowd pleasers) and the have nots
(broader market) continues to grow.
With
the bond market taking a much needed day off on Monday, today's big cap
rally will be given a free rein to continue for another day, but don't
expect it to last.
Also in the
'don't expect it to last' category is this week's plunge in oil
prices. The decline in oil prices is one part correction from
extremely overbought levels, and two parts fear that the resolve of some
OPEC nations to maintain production cuts is wavering. The continued
weakness of many OPEC economies, and their dependence on higher oil prices
to kick start nascent economic recoveries, will quickly force any
errant members back in to line.
10/07/99
As
earnings season kicks off, the initial results are living up to pre-season
expectations, but a divergence of opinion has appeared when it comes to
translating the phrase "better than expected" into action.
On one side of the street the phrase is a cause for celebration, while on
the other side of the road it is met with a shrug and a sell order.
The divergent reactions shown thus far
when earnings surpass expectations mirrors the steadily widening
divergence in sentiment that has become unmistakable in recent
months. The broader market is keenly aware that the winds have
shifted, that the once perfect set of circumstances is rapidly departing,
and with its departure, the environment has turned inhospitable.
There exists a tiny segment of the market, however, where complacency
still reigns despite the deterioration that has taken place in the outside
world.
The market's reaction to better than
expected earnings from General Electric and Yahoo illustrates the rapidly
growing sentiment chasm that is developing, with Yahoo riding a euphoria
driven wave to a 14 point gain, while GE dips a point as the 'sell on the
news' camp that thrashed Dow component Alcoa into submission yesterday
returns for a second engagement.
Divergences, whether intramarket or
intermarket, whether they show their face in the advance/decline line or
in market sentiment, are never a positive force, and they always have a
way of working themselves out, and more times than not they are resolved
by the minority rejoining the majority. When the divergences are
kept alive by euphoric sentiment alone, and when the very
circumstances that initially allowed euphoria to flourish no longer exist,
the eventual shakeout process can be brutal, sparing no prisoners in its
wake.
Now, we're not saying that the NASDAQ is
about to crash immediately, far from it, for with the NASDAQ composite
within 4 points of its old highs a sneeze will be enough to carry it to a
new high, and euphoria could be enough to carry it the rest of the way to
3000.
Sawed-off euphoria, that dangerous
variety of excessive feel-good sentiment that remains even after the
favorable environmental supports that initially gave birth to it have been
removed (or sawed off), is the most dangerous variety of euphoria because
it forces its adherents to live in a vacuum, one that blinds them to the
negative changes that have occurred in the broader world around them, a
blindness that act to accentuate the pain on the downside when the limits
of euphoria have been reached.
NASDAQ's current run at its old highs,
driven by a narrow group of stocks that have anointed the most bubblesque
of the group as their chosen leaders, is not a sign of renewed market
strength, unconfirmed highs never are, but rather it is another in the
series of warning bells that have been sounding with increasing regularity
that the market has topped out, that only the weak hands remain to steer
the ship through the waters of a suddenly inhospitable environment (a ship
that many insiders at crowd pleasing NASDAQ Internet and technology
companies have been jumping off of at an accelerating pace as the year has
progressed).
Finally, the Dow stocks may be 0 for 2
in their attempts this week to translate strong earnings numbers into
higher stock prices, but the world's central bankers are 2 for 0 this week
in their attempts to send a message, with the ECB joining the Fed this
morning in moving towards a tighter bias.
10/06/99
One day after the wrecking ball swung in
a wide arc across the landscape, one day after uncertainty and trepidation
ruled the town, the pieces are being picked up and composure has been
regained, but the pace of rebuilding is an uneven one, with some
neighborhoods recovering faster than others, and the bright skies a little
less bright on second glance.
Call it relief, call it complacency, or
call it the return of earnings anticipation fever, but the market is
making a valiant attempt to put the past behind it and emerge from the no
man's land, the whipsaw zone that it found itself mired in at the close of
trading on Tuesday.
It is a bright day on the street as the
market races upward, but the day's rally is indistinguishable from many
rallies that have preceded it in recent months, with the brightness
dissipating as one surveys the broader market landscape. The
percentage gains gradually decrease as one moves away from the market
leaders, with the usual suspects bringing up the rear: the utilities, the
Russell 2000, the transports, the U.S. Dollar Index, and the long bond.
In short, it is more of the same, a top
heavy rally skewed towards the new Nifty 50 and the crowd pleasing .coms,
in short, a market where divergences continue to grow. Despite a 2%
gain in the NASDAQ and a better than 160 point runup in the Dow, advancing
issues are barely leading declining issues, with the margin just 250 on
the NYSE and 270 on the NASDAQ.
It is unlikely that today's rally is the
start of anything new. In order for the market to mount a
sustainable new leg up we will need to see the laggards pickup the pace,
with their percentage gains equaling or surpassing those of the current
narrow basket of crowd pleasing leaders.
The factors that have led to today's
rally, relief and pre-earnings anticipation fervor, are unlikely to remain
around long enough to spark a fire under the broader market.
When hopes build in anticipation of an
outcome that is at the top end of the possible spectrum, the actual
attainment of the best possible outcome is more times than not an
emotional letdown. Translation: with expectations running high,
expect selling on the news to dominate this earnings season as
expectations are met. We have already seen this as Alcoa, the first
of the Dow 30 stocks to report, was summarily taken out and shot after
meeting analysts estimates this morning. Earnings season is likely
to bring more pain than joy, as only the stocks that exceed their
"whisper number" are left to rally.
Relief, the second factor in today's
rally, is also likely to be short-lived. A belief has developed that
uncertainty will end when the Fed makes its anticipated third move, that 3
is somehow a magic cure-all. In reality, the Fed's job will not be
done until the underlying economic imbalances and inflationary pressures
that have been slowly building beneath the surface are alleviated, and the
extent of the move necessary to ease the pressures remains up in the air
at this point.
It is not just the Fed, however, that
investors in the U.S. stock market must fear. While all eyes are on
Greenspan & Co, the European Central Bank also poses a direct
threat to the U.S. stock and bond markets. While we do not foresee a
move to hike rates at tomorrow's ECB meeting, the accelerating pace of
European growth is increasing the likelihood of a move in the not too
distant future. A move by the ECB would exert a strong downward
pressure on the dollar, pressure that would be felt in short order in
other U.S. financial markets.
Enjoy today's rally while it lasts.
10/05/99
There's
one at every party, the party pooper, the one who seems to make a career
of spoiling a good time, the one who arrives and puts a damper on the fun
just when things are looking up...and when the party pooper brings along
11 friends for reinforcement, even the best of times can quickly
turn sour, as evidenced by today's mid day market plunge.
The party wrecker and his 11 cohorts
arrived on schedule shortly after 2 p.m., and quickly brought an end to
the day's pre-victory celebration, stunning the gathered crowd with an
announcement that while nothing had changed, things might change in the
future.
The crowd, who had been under the
misguided impression that the passing of Summer and arrival of Fall signaled
the downfall of their arch nemesis Mr. Uncertainty von Ratejitter, quickly
panicked, fleeing the gathering en masse. The panicked departure
continued for an hour but quickly ebbed after the the Cheerleaders of
Panic, Mr. & Mrs. Bondmarketti, had made their final exit.
The remaining partygoers were left
standing around, jaws agape, to ponder the aftermath of the unexpected monkey wrench
that had been thrown into their festivities. The question, "whither
from here?", that echoed throughout the air, resonating off the walls
and floors, was a simple one, but one without a clear-cut immediate
answer.
The participants were left adrift in a
sea of uncertainty, a place that they had become all too familiar with
over the past few five months, and a place from which the euphoria of
Spring and early Summer is unlikely to sprout anew. It is a place
where rallies are quick and unsustainable, their growth quickly stunted
when contact is made with the emotion draining flyswatter wielded by their
nemesis Uncertainty von Ratejitter.
Little has changed with today's adoption
of a bias towards tightening by the Fed. The numbing game of living
economic report to economic report will continue, with the market
continuing to swing wildly from complacency to despondency, the tenure of
each emotion lasting only as long as the time span between the release of
the bits of economic data.
As today's market
chart shows, the stock market ended the day in a virtual no go zone, a
no man's land, it's upper bounds marked by today's high of 10509 on the
Dow, its lower bounds marked by the afternoon's panic low of Dow
10277. The area in between today's highs and lows should be
considered a no go zone where whipsaws rather than profits will result.
In the short term, on a move beyond
either boundary of today's range, we would expect a powerful, but short-lived
and unsustainable, movement to development.
In the longer term, the uncertainty will
continue until the rate hike cycle is at an end, an end which will only
come about when the current torrid pace of above trend consumer demand
eases. At this point, continued strong demand and Greenspan era Fed
history point (with rate hikes following 8 out of 11 moves to a tighter
bias during Greenspan's era) to a third rate hike.
The market will receive its first real
dose of post FOMC economic data, and direction, on Friday with the release
of September's Hurricane Floyd skewed employment numbers.
The real danger to the stock market at
this point is that the anticipated rate hike number three will be followed
by numbers four, or five, an event which the majority of market
participants have yet to consider. With consumer spending undeterred by
this year's rise in interest rates, and with the global economy on the
mend and signs of inflation emerging at the producer level, the
possibility cannot be ruled out that the action required by the Fed will
last longer, and be far more severe, than presently anticipated.
At this point, with uncertainty once
again the dominant sentiment, and with the majority of stocks remaining in
downtrends, the odds continue to favor a resolution of the current market
uncertainty to the downside, and caution rather than shooting for the
fences remains the key to
survival.
10/04/99
Mondays,
the day the punters return to the battlefield rejuvenated and ready to
face another week of ups and downs, a day for new beginnings and fresh
starts, a day for new attitudes and fresh hope, a day when misplaced
complacency borne of false hopes can lead to a week of turmoil and strife.
Earnings season anticipation, mergers
and rumored mergers, slipping oil prices, a declining yen for yen, and a
near unanimous belief that the Fed will stand pat tomorrow combined to
send stocks and bonds higher this morning, a rally broad enough to entice
even the downtrodden transports and utilities.
On a purely technical level, the pieces
for this morning's rally began to fall into place about 40 minutes before
Friday's close when one of our favorite indicators gave a (very short
term) buy signal on the 5-minute chart (and only on the 5-minute chart) of
the Dow Industrials. On a purely fundamental level, the release of
Japan's Tankan survey (which showed confidence at a 21 month high, but
capital spending plans still in the doldrums) set the wheels in motion for
a rally. Add to the mix telecom giant Sprint in play, falling oil
prices, a strong dollar (against the yen), and a belief that third quarter
earnings will be strong, and the market had nowhere to go but up this
morning.
The key question now is, "will it
remain up ?". Not likely.
Third quarter earnings will be stellar,
but everyone has known that they will be for months, and the majority of
players have already placed their bets. The upcoming earnings season
is likely to prove to be a disappointment, just as the eagerly anticipated
second quarter earnings period fizzled when it finally came. Selling
on the news will likely be the norm, with only those companies that
comfortably exceed their whisper number escaping unharmed.
While we expect selling on the news to
dominate, we expect to see it occur at a lower intensity than it did in
July--the market enters this earnings period leaning to the overconfident
side, but emotions are running far below the euphoria of early July.
All in all, we expect the upcoming earnings season to be a relative
nonevent for the market, an event which is likely to be overshadowed by
the continuing presence of the market's arch enemy: uncertainty.
After today's brief respite, we expect
to see uncertainty return with a vengeance in the not too distant future
as the crowds of bird watchers who have gathered in Washington D.C. return
home disappointed that the expected sighting of the flock of 12 benevolent
doves never materialized, disappointed that the 'all's clear' signal was
not sounded.
Today a rally and a touch of
complacency, tomorrow a change in bias and a bit of despondency. On
the fundamental side, strong consumer demand powering the economy at full
steam will continue to make rallies like today's unsustainable until
demand eases.
On the technical front, Friday's short
term buy signal just turned into a sell signal, and after making a brief
foray above the 10402 resistance level and falling back, the Dow's second
run at the morning highs has failure written all over it, with divergences
abounding...and that's only on the 5-minute chart.
On longer term charts, the sell signal
was never lifted, and the market remains in a downtrend, with preservation
of capital remaining the first task of the day, and using rallies like
today's to take profits is a key to survival.
Copyright � 1998-2002 Tulips and Bears LLC.
All Rights Reserved. Republication of this material,
including posting to message boards or news groups,
without the prior written consent of Tulips and Bears LLC
is strictly prohibited. 'Tulips and Bears' is a registered trademark of
Tulips and Bears LLC
Last modified: April 02, 2001
Published By Tulips and Bears
LLC